A CFD-Based Comparative Analysis of Passive and Active Winglets for Narrow-Body Aircraft: Aerodynamic Performance, Fuel Efficiency, And Structural Trade-Offs
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract: This study presents a high-fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-based comparative analysis of passive and active winglet configurations for narrow-body aircraft, focusing on aerodynamic performance, fuel efficiency, and structural trade-offs. While passive winglets are widely implemented due to their simplicity and drag-reduction benefits, active winglets offer adaptive geometry modulation, enhancing performance across various flight phases. Using an Airbus A320-style model, CFD simulations were conducted under standardized cruise conditions to quantify lift (Cl), drag (Cd), and the lift-to-drag ratio (L/D), complemented by scoring for structural complexity and maintenance. The results revealed that the active winglet outperformed the passive configuration, yielding a 10.5% L/D improvement and up to a 6.11% drag reduction during cruise, which translates to fuel savings of 3.87–6.11% across takeoff, cruise, and descent. However, the trade-off analysis highlighted significantly increased structural, actuation, and maintenance demands in active systems. As a solution, a hybrid winglet design—combining passive-flex tips with low-degree-of-freedom actuators—was proposed to balance aerodynamic gains with integration feasibility. The study contributes novel, CFD-driven, regionally contextualized data to sustainable aircraft design, particularly in the context of Southeast Asia’s aviation sector. Limitations include the lack of wind tunnel validation and simplified actuator modeling. Future research should focus on prototyping, aeroelastic simulation, and the integration of AI-based real-time control. The findings offer practical insights for fleet retrofitting and next-generation aerodynamic optimization.
Downloads
References
Adams, E. (2017, June 21). Airbus' big bet to save its dying A380 super jumbo: Winglets. WIRED. https://www.wired.com/story/airbus-a380plus-winglets/
Al Sidairi, K. A., & Rameshkumar, G. (2016). Design of winglet device for aircraft. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Sciences and Engineering, 7(1). http://www.ijmse.org/Volume7/Issue1/paper4.pdf
Alamy. (2024). Airbus A320 Sharklets. Alamy. https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo/airbus-a320-sharklets-ctarbn.html?sortBy=relevant
Amendola, G., Dimino, I., Concilio, A., Andreutti, G., Pecora, R., & Cascio, M.L. (2017). Preliminary Design Process for an Adaptive Winglet. https://doi.org/10.18178/IJMERR.7.1.83-92
Aviation Partners. (2024). Types of blended winglets. Aviation Partners. https://www.aviationpartners.com/aircraft-winglets/types-blended-winglets/
Bairwa, N., Jain, A., & Rajawat, A. (2016). A study on winglets and their contribution to aerodynamics. International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, 3(6), 2474-2478. https://www.irjet.net/archives/V3/i6/IRJET-V3I647.pdf
Belferhat, S., Meftah, S. M. A., Yahiaoui, T., & Imine, B. (2013). Aerodynamic optimization of a winglet design. In EPJ Web of Conferences (Vol. 45, p. 01010). EDP Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/20134501010
Berens, M. (2008). Potential of Multi-Winglet Systems to Improve Aircraft Performance. https://api-depositonce.tu-berlin.de/server/api/core/bitstreams/bac419f2-38a7-48a2-b30f-b2d6b418e37d/content
Bertorelli, P. (2019). Active winglets: Bolt-on efficiency. Aviation Consumer. https://www.aviationconsumer.com/aircraftreviews/aircraftstepups/active-winglets-bolt-on-efficiency/
Bravo-Mosquera, P. D., Catalano, F. M., & Zingg, D. W. (2022). Unconventional aircraft for civil aviation: A review of concepts and design methodologies. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 131, 100813. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paerosci.2022.100813
Caliskan, S. (2014). Experimental investigation of heat transfer in a channel with new winglet-type vortex generators. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 78, 604–614. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2014.07.043
Chandra, D., & Misra, A. (2023). Impact of implementing winglets on the aerodynamic performance of an aircraft: A review. International Journal of Mechanical and Thermal Engineering. https://doi.org/10.22271/27078043.2023.v4.i1a.50
Crawley, E.F. (1994). Intelligent structures for aerospace - A technology overview and assessment. AIAA Journal, 32, 1689-1699. https://doi.org/10.2514/3.12161
De Breuker, R., Mkhoyan, T., Nazeer, N., Stuber, V.L., Wang, X., Mkhoyan, I., Groves, R.M., van der Zwaag, S., & Sodja, J. (2022). Overview of the SmartX Wing Technology Integrator. Actuators. https://doi.org/10.3390/act11100302
Dimino, I., Andreutti, G., Moens, F., Fonte, F., Pecora, R., & Concilio, A. (2021). Integrated Design of a Morphing Winglet for Active Load Control and Alleviation of Turboprop Regional Aircraft. Applied Sciences, 11(5), 2439. https://doi.org/10.3390/app11052439
Eguea, J.P., Catalano, F.M., Abdalla, Á.M., Santana, L.D., Venner, C.H., & Silva, A.L. (2018). Study on a Camber Adaptive Winglet. 2018 Applied Aerodynamics Conference. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2018-3960
Eightyknots. (2014, April 21). How do you choose the best wing tip device?. Recreational Flying. https://recreationalflying.com/forums/topic/22717-how-do-you-choose-the-best-wing-tip-device/
Fahd, R. (2021, August 31). Evolution of winglets. Medium. https://rahmanfahd.medium.com/evolution-of-winglets-8d5b3ba5a929
Gatto, A., Bourdin, P., & Friswell, M. I. (2011). Experimental Investigation into the Control and Load Alleviation Capabilities of Articulated Winglets. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 2012. https://doi.org/10.1155/2012/789501
Gavrilović, N. N., Rašuo, B. P., Dulikravich, G. S., & Parezanović, V. B. (2015). Commercial aircraft performance improvement using winglets. FME Transactions, 43(1), 1-8. https://hal.science/hal-04521084/
Guerrero, J., Wittkowski, K., & Sanguineti, M. (2019). Variable cant angle winglets for the improvement of aircraft flight performance. Meccanica, 55, 1917 - 1947. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-020-01230-1
Henderson, W., and Holmes, B., "Induced Drag - Historical Perspective," SAE Technical Paper 892341, 1989, https://doi.org/10.4271/892341.
Kolappan, S., Manickam, I. N., Swikker, K. R. J., Gnanaraj, S. J. P., & Appadurai, M. (2022). Performance analysis of aircraft composite winglet. Materials Today: Proceedings, 62, 889-895. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2022.04.061
Majid, T., & Jo, B. W. (2020). Status and Challenges on Design and Implementation of Camber Morphing Mechanisms. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 2021(1), 6399937. https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/6399937
Maughmer, M. D. (2003). Design of winglets for high-performance sailplanes. Journal of aircraft, 40(6), 1099–1106. https://doi.org/10.2514/2.7220
Maughmer, M., & Kunz, P. (1998). Sailplane winglet design. Technical Soaring, 22(4), 116–123. https://journals.sfu.ca/ts/index.php/ts/article/view/421
Maughmer, M.D. (2006). The Design of Winglets for Low-Speed Aircraft. Technical Soaring, 30, 6173. http://www.mandhsoaring.com/Why%20Winglets/WL-IT.pdf
Merryisha, S., & Rajendran, P. (2019). Review of Winglets on Tip Vortex, Drag and Airfoil Geometry. https://www.akademiabaru.com/doc/ARFMTSV63_N2_P218_237.pdf
Monner, H. P., & Sinapius, M., et al. (2020). Active aerodynamic devices in civil aircraft: Current status and future perspectives. CEAS Aeronautical Journal, 11, 795–810. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13272-020-00465-8
Narayan, G., & John, B. (2016). Effect of winglets induced tip vortex structure on the performance of subsonic wings. Aerospace Science and Technology, 58, 328-340. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ast.2016.08.031
Norris, G. (2021). Winglets evolve to boost efficiency across aircraft spectrum. Aviation Week. https://aviationweek.com/mro/aircraft-propulsion/winglets-evolve-boost-efficiency-across-aircraft-spectrum
Öztürk, Ş., & Örs, İ. (2020). An overview for effects on aerodynamic performance of using winglets and wingtip devices on aircraft. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/An-overview-for-effects-on-aerodynamic-performance-%C3%96zt%C3%BCrk-%C3%96rs/b6e4fee8bcaa2bf1de9913ab62fbd8efb5e6d40b
Panagiotou, P., Kaparos, P., & Yakinthos, K. (2014). Winglet design and optimization for a MALE UAV using CFD. Aerospace Science and Technology, 39, 190-205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ast.2014.09.006
Paul, J.O., Gabriel, O.E., & Abbe, G. (2020). Active Tip Fins for Box Wing Aircraft. Recent Patents on Engineering, 14, 268-272. https://doi.org/10.2174/1872212113666190226162215
Samuel Merryisha, & Parvathy Rajendran. (2024). Review of Winglets on Tip Vortex, Drag and Airfoil Geometry. Journal of Advanced Research in Fluid Mechanics and Thermal Sciences, 63(2), 218–237. https://semarakilmu.com.my/journals/index.php/fluid_mechanics_thermal_sciences/article/view/3618
Siliang, D., Qijun, Z., & Zhengfei, T. (2019). Numerical Simulation of the Effect of Different Number Leading Edge Winglets on the Fan-Wing Aerodynamic Characteristics. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 2020(1), 8941453. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8941453
Smith, M., Komerath, N., Ames, R., Wong, O., & Pearson, J. (2001). Performance analysis of a wing with multiple winglets. In 19th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference (p. 2407). https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2001-2407
SOLTANI, M. R., MASDARI, M., & TIRANDAZ, M. R. (2017). Effect of an end plate on surface pressure distributions of two swept wings. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics, 30(5), 1631–1643. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cja.2017.07.008
Tamarack Aerospace. (2024). Tamarack Active Winglet technology. Tamarack Aerospace Group. https://www.tamarackaero.com/technology
Tobin, N., Hamed, A. M., & Chamorro, L. P. (2015). An experimental study on the effects of winglets on the wake and performance of a model wind turbine. Energies, 8(10), 11955-11972. https://doi.org/10.3390/en81011955
Ursache, N.M., Melin, T., Isikveren, A.T., & Friswell, M.I. (2007). Morphing Winglets for Aircraft Multi-phase Improvement. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2007-7813
Woodrow, E. (2019). Winglet evolution continues with active winglets. Aviation Maintenance Magazine. https://www.avm-mag.com/winglet-evolution-continues-with-active-winglets
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
All articles published in our journal are licensed under CC-BY 4.0, which permits authors to retain copyright of their work. This license allows for unrestricted use, sharing, and reproduction of the articles, provided that proper credit is given to the original authors and the source.